Bethesda Injunction Appeal Denied in Fallout Legal Dispute

Posted Thu, Oct 27, 2011 by Martuk

The courtroom drama between Interplay and Bethesda continues this week. Joystiq is reporting that Fallout IP owner Bethesda has suffered another setback in their legal battle against Interplay over the Fallout Online MMOG license.

According to the story, Bethesda appealed the ruling of a district court that rejected their previous filing for a preliminary injunction against Interplay stating that, “the district court abused its discretion and misapplied the law in concluding that Bethesda failed to establish a likelihood of irreparable harm." Bethesda also argued that Interplay’s financial crisis could cause harm them harm if the developer entered into bankruptcy.

If Bethesda felt that the district court had abused its discretion they are probably feeling really violated right now since the United States Court of Appeals agreed with the earlier ruling and Bethesda’s claim was once again rejected.

The Fallout legal battle is a long way from over, but for now at least, Interplay can continue work on Fallout Online.  But the court document does state one other major hurdle that Interplay will have to jump if they want to bring Fallout Online to the market.  The document states that, “There can be no launch of an MMOG by Interplay without express permission from Bethesda.” Given how ugly and lengthy this legal fight has been, that could be one huge hurdle.

You can read the full court document at Joystiq.

Source: Joystiq


The long and messy legal battle between Bethesda and Interplay over the Fallout IP has finally been settled.

Tue, Jan 03, 2012

The Bethesda vs Interplay saga heads to court this month and reaches a new level of ridiculousness.

Fri, Dec 02, 2011

Bethesda loses another round to Interplay in the courtroom following a rejected injunction appeal that allows Interplay’s work on Fallout Online to continue.

Thu, Oct 27, 2011

Bethesda suffers another setback in their Fallout IP legal battle with Interplay after a judge dismisses their move for a restraining order against co-developer Masthead Studios.

Fri, Sep 23, 2011

News from around the 'Net