If you haven't read the Penny Arcade "review" of EverQuest 2, I wouldn't even bother wasting your time. Instead, head over to Aggrome's well written blog, where he analyzes what they said.

Now, note that when you click on the Penny Arcade comic link it takes you to the EQII "review" and not the comic. How convenient. But, hey that's Blizzard's issue, not Penny Arcade's.

What is their issue is doing work for Blizzard on the Official Strategy Guide. They also promote WoW heavily and even had a booth at Blizzcon. That's a problem when you're attempting to review games made by their direct competitor. You could at least say, "Hey, we do work for the Official WoW Strategy Guide, so take this commentary with a grain of salt."

This is well worth it to check out here