Exclusive City of Heroes Issue 13 Interview with Matt Miller and Brian Clayton
by Cody “Micajah” Bye, Managing Editor
style="font-weight: bold; font-style: italic;">
by City of Heroes’ Brian Clayton (Executive Producer) and
Matt Miller (Lead Designer)
The phrase “user generated content” is one that
gets tossed around a lot these days and for good reason. Massively
multiplayer online game developers love the idea of creating a feature
in a game that is relatively organic and can grow through the users
rather than through the developers. With that in mind, the href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/taxonomy/term/140"
Heroes team set to work on the Mission Architect and have
plenty of praise for the decision. However, the team href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/node/44968" target="_blank">recently
that the Architect was being pushed back until Issue 14
rather than its
projected Issue 13 release. Ten Ton Hammer’s Cody
“Micajah” Bye got on the phone with NC
NorCal’s Matt Miller and Brian Clayton to learn the details
of this decision and what players can expect from the newly dubbed
Ten Ton Hammer: What can
you tell us about the delay of the Mission Architect? Why was it
Architect is delayed until Issue 14.
By taking the time to launch Mission Architect as robustly as possible,
we never really nailed down a launch date for Issue 13. Now we're just
really taking the time to make sure the Mission Architect is AAA, is
complete, and will push the MMO genre forward. But we also didn't want
to hold back all this great content we've been working on for the last
Really, it's a win-win for the customers across the board in the sense
that they're getting great content off the development line and they're
getting the Mission Architect exactly the way that they hoped it would
Ten Ton Hammer: Can you
explain to our readers and City of Heroes fans why it was so difficult
to add customizable characters into the Mission Architect? Why did it
force you to move the Mission Architect to Issue 14?
We wanted to insure that the customizable characters that we were
putting in were as customizable as possible. We had a pencil sketch
plan of how you'd be able to do this, but when we looked at it in more
detail, there were just a lot of the little things that were breaking
in the missions and it was not going to be as easy as we thought it
The AI in particular doesn't really know how to use a lot of the powers
that the players wanted in their, unless we use a specific type of AI.
So we have to go and get that AI written and make sure people have the
customization that they want from these guys and make the animations
look correct. Some of the abilities have specifically tailored
animations and so you can't just slap a particular character model on
to any set of powers.
That's just one of thirty different little problems involved in getting
these things working, but we all knew that once we got this in it is
really what we should be launching with the Architect.
Ten Ton Hammer: Is the
character customization in the Architect as robust as what players have
in their own character creation? Or are players going to be limited?
Matt: We are
making it as robust as possible, but there are some powers that players
have access to that the AI won't be able to handle, like the Mastermind
summoning powers. We would have to program a specific AI just for that.
It's just something we haven't done before.
most important thing that most of the players are requesting is the
ability to change the costumes and customize the look of the bosses and
things like that in the mission creator. Both of these features were
going to be a part of the next phase of the mission creator, but
because of the overwhelming response to the mission creator and the
need for that feature in particular, we really just wanted to listen to
our customers and give them what they really want. And it's
not just the ability to make great content but to be able to specialize
and personalize it as well.
Ten Ton Hammer: So these
customized characters are mainly bosses and NPCs players can fight
They're mainly the "main" villains and allies you'll play with with
the Mission Architect, there are still plenty of interesting features
in Issue 13.
Ten Ton Hammer: Even with
the Mission Architect out of Issue 13, you're still tacking on a bunch
of new features into this next Issue. Were those features ready for
Issue 13, or did you speed up the development of those mechanics
because you knew that the Architect was getting delayed?
Matt: A lot
of them were ready for 13, but we just hadn't announced 'em yet. A
couple of them - at least one that I know of - did get a bit of an
acceleration to make sure we could get it into 13.
Ten Ton Hammer: The new
features that you've added are pretty neat - at least on paper. I
especially like the "Leveling Pact" idea. Do you think this is going to
unbalance the game in some way? There are people who play MMOs all the
time; will this shovel a whole ton of people to the end cap of the game?
will be a lot more people hitting the level cap with this, but our hope
is that it won't take less time to get to the end game simply because
you're earning XP at half rate because you're getting two characters to
the next level.
With that in mind, there will be more characters there, but it will
still take the same amount of time that it would've taken the same two
players to do it individually.
But it's also a social tool. Just like side-kicking let me
play with my friends, this actually takes me to that next step in
social gaming. Me and my friend are always going to be in lockstep with
each other, even if we end up playing at two completely different times
during the day.
Ten Ton Hammer: Can you
talk about Multi-Builds? These seems like a pretty neat PvE / PvP
is something that a lot of our PvP players have been asking about for a
long time. They really wanted the ability to have a certain power set
choice and ehnancement load outs for PvP rather than for PvE. Looking
at that, we decided to make it not just a PvP feature, but a universal
feature. If you want a solo and a group build, you can do that. If you
want a PvP and PvE build, you can do that. If you want a Task Force
build and a normal play build, you can do that.
We're really leaving the option of the other build up to the players.
If they don't want to deal with having to swap out a build for their
character, they don't need to touch the system. It's completely
optional to the player.
Ten Ton Hammer: They only
have one set, correct?
we're only launch with one available. That doesn't mean the option
isn't there for other build slots in the future.
Ten Ton Hammer: Can you
talk about the power rebalancing at all? How are you balancing you PvP
and PvE powers?
really be seeing changes in Issue 13.
Matt: One of
the things when we started the studio was to make hires in the "Powers"
department. Not only do we have more people to work on the powers, but
we can also now take a fine-toothed comb to the power system and get
some data mining and cold hard facts on the powers and how they're
To start, we rebalanced the Patron powers and the Epic powers that
villains and heroes get so they're more in line with each other. We
looked at what players were picking more often and changed some powers
completely and pruned some powers.
In addition, we wanted to make sure PvP remained fun. We were getting
into a situation with the games because PvP was getting less and less
fun because of how some powers interacted with players. Back then, we
couldn't adjust the powers without having an adjustment made in PvE as
well. Basically, we got more people, had more code time, and created a
new technology system so that when you're in a PvP zone some powers act
very differently than what they do in PvE. Hopefully this will bring a
more balanced PvP game to the CoX franchise and allow new players to
find this enjoyable.
Ten Ton Hammer: You
talked about Issue 14 very very briefly in the press release. Can you
give us any hints about what the other features are going to be besides
the Mission Architect?
Matt: I wish
I could, but marketing would lunge across the table to stop me.
Ten Ton Hammer: (laughs)
Matt: But if
you read between the lines, you could probably infer some features.
Ten Ton Hammer: Is there
anything else you'd like to tell the readers and CoH fans?
Talking about the title - Power and Responsibility - basically we
thought it was a perfect title that really fit all these features that
are going to be in this Issue. We have all these new power sets,
players can choose their own rewards in the merit system, the new
rebalancing in PvP, and the "day job" stuff to show what kind of
responsibilities characters have beyond fighting crime or causing
Of course, obviously the quote used by the great Stan Lee and the idea
that we as a studio have a great responsibility in getting the players
these features as fast as possible. A lot of these things are ready to
go and we're tightening down the bolts on the last few things before we
can send this to the training room for players to see. It would be
irresponsible of us to not get this in the fans of players.
To read the latest guides, news, and features you can visit our City of Villains Game Page.