Archive

WildStar Burst: A Raid Discussion

Posted Tue, Mar 11, 2014 by Lewis B

Raids are an important part of WildStar's end game content, but why do so many players want this specific activity?

WildStar-Burst

Raids are an oddity for many. Not only do they require a huge commitment on behalf of the individual participating but also from the entire guild. Raids aren’t an area to be taken lightly and there are often hurdles to take, at a basic guild level, that make it a gated and internally competitive affair.

I recently applied to a guild and am generally used to the whole process (though I’ve been with my previous guild for the past 7 years). An application form, interview and mandatory event attendance is pretty standard and yet when I raised this with my brother recently, he looked at me as if I’d just shot him: “You actually have to apply?”. It must have taken him by surprise as he actually paused the game he was playing.

It’s fair to say that not all guilds operate in this fashion and there are plenty in the Beta that will invite you freely and expect nothing more from you than being a member. However should you wish to participate in raids and Warplots with a semblance of organization and a hope of completing them within a reasonable timescale, something above that of a “casual” guild is almost mandatory even if the process of entering into such guilds is ridiculous.

WildStar

I must stress that I hate the terms “casual”, “semi-hardcore” or “hardcore” as they’re a very lazy way of placing people into brackets based on raw playing times as opposed to skill or understanding. Where these “hardcore” guilds are concerned, you’ll usually find mandatory attendance of 3 days is a minimum and while that’s more than acceptable for many, I’ve always found such an approach a little odd. I fully appreciate the fact that not having attendance parameters can royally screw over a raiding guild, especially when players don’t turn up, and yet it’s easily countered by recruiting based on playing times as opposed to enforcing mandatory days (that tends to just piss people off). 

My raiding experience, like most people, varies and is primarily linked to World of Warcraft and was often fueled by frustration, elitism, DKP misery and one hit wonders (I’ll discuss those later). Without doubt the experience of defeating a boss, for the first time and not the 50th, was brilliant, but when combined with random loot pools and fighting for drops with 5 other Druids made raiding feel much more like a chore than an occasion of celebration and camaraderie. Part of the problem behind this however was often the infrastructure surrounding guilds in game and that they were all too often left to their own devices as to how to distribute loot and how to organise raids. Developers put too little attention into the raiding framework to support guilds properly. 

DKP for anyone who has ever encountered it, is a blessing and a curse for the genre. Depending on your raid leader, you’ll be awarded X amounts of points (kept on a spreadsheet offline) that you can then bid with in an effort to obtain loot dropped from downed enemies. It’s inevitably your choice as to what you spend your points on or whether you’ll save them up for the best items. I’m hopeful that a mod can be made to accommodate this approach if guilds want it, otherwise we're left with a paper headache.

Digressing a little and coming back to the “one hit wonders”, I came up against these players constantly in my raiding days. Basically, they’re the players that only show up for raids and raids only. They suck up DKP, obtain the best gear and then you never see them for the rest of the week. There’s nothing particularly wrong with it (besides it being super annoying for those of us who actually play the game outside of raiding confines) but it’s just one of the many frustrations in a raiding environment. 

Why then, with all the issues that a raid inflicts on its players, are we so keen to see raids in WildStar? You know what, I’m not really sure. I do enjoy raiding will participating but they're a huge resource drain on development, take months of testing and planning and don’t lend themselves well to repeat play. I suppose however that it all boils down to overcoming something difficult as a group but, I feel that in itself is a bit misleading. I’ve often felt that raid difficulty is only scaled up based on the number of players involved, which inevitably relies on everyone being on the top of their game. Perhaps the draw of raids is to bash something big over the head and feel anxious over the loot it drops or perhaps it appeals to our most basic needs to conquer something and soak in the glory alongside friends. 

WildStar

As for Warplots, I think for the most part they’ll inherit the same issues as raids with the exception being your Warplot will be destroyed and your guild will likely squabble as to what went wrong (I blame Espers already - I kid, I kid!) although, guilds tend to squabble when they wipe on raids anyway. 

Overall WildStar’s raiding has every potential to meet and exceed that of World of Warcraft, especially with the challenge of telegraphs and looser trinities. I just hope that in the process Carbine provide us with the tools to go about it fairly and from the lessons they’ve learnt with Adventures, attempt to mix up our progression to keep things fresh. 

P.S If you’re a one hit wonder, you’re on my kill on sight list. 

I love raiding (if a game doesn't have atleast 10 man raiding, I am not interested) because its nice to group up with a bunch of people and just work together to do something. I do the same for Planetside 2, love grouping up with my outfit to attack a base :-P

As someone who fits(or used to fit) your definition of a "one-hit wonder," I can't help but wonder what you have against us.

I raided very seriously, but had a limited schedule. Typically, all I could manage to play was the four main raiding days, and often it would be so tight on time that it would be a struggle for me to maintain the very demanding consumable and enchantment requirements of a top guild, as I'd often have less than 2-3 hours to play on my own each week. I couldn't have played more if I wanted to.

Somewhat related, it's this experience as a time-limited player that makes me absolutely disgusted by anyone who uses time played as an excuse or a classification of player. Casual and Hardcore aren't about how much you play, they're attitudes.

I think my issue with one hit wonders stems from experiences I've had with those types of players. I'm not suggesting all players who follow this format are the same, but two particular players I've encountered spring to mind. Both the individuals raided twice a week (which is fine) but because they attended every raid without fail and had such high quantities of DKP, they never failed to get first dibs. Inevitably, this resulted in them obtaining the best items but spending 5 days a week offline, not helping the guild in any other areas. When other members of the guild spent 5 days online but were weaker as a result, it felt a little odd. Now I'm not suggesting they did anything wrong and the whole problem is as a result of the raid system and a need for attendance, but it always rubbed me up the wrong way for some reason..

The other side of the argument is the fact that in your circumstance, it's a shame that you have to raid and spend your only free time raiding for fear of missing out on gear.

I think it's quite a different situation when you're only raiding two days a week. While it's certainly possible that they don't have the time to play a lot, I'd imagine they were simply playing on multiple characters. They likely had another guild they were raiding in. That would piss off anyone who takes raiding seriously.

That said, if a player is spending 5 days a week online, are they not attending all of your raids? It seems to me that they should have just as much chance as your two-day guys.

WarriorLarge.jpg

In this guide we provide you with all you need to know about the Warrior.

Guides
Thu, Jun 19, 2014
Lewis B
WildStar: The Strain

We met up with the folks from Carbine Studios during E3 2014 for a preview of the first major content update for WildStar, The Strain, and talked to Jeremy Gaffney about what it will bring to the live game.

Features, Interviews
Wed, Jun 18, 2014
Barlow
StalkerLarge.jpg

In this guide we provide you with all you need to know about the Stalker.

Guides
Fri, Jun 20, 2014
Lewis B
WildStar

In this guide we provide you with a complete overview of WildStars path system.

Guides
Tue, Jun 17, 2014
Lewis B

News from around the 'Net