noted before
that free-to-play (F2P) games have a very short
window of opportunity (maybe 3-5 hours) to hook a player. By contrast,
gamers who buy a box for a pay-to-play (P2P) game in a store feel
compelled to try a game for the 30 days they get with the purchase of
the box. It’s one of the reasons I think  href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/node/50655">more F2P games
should explore retail boxes. The key to the appeal of P2P
games is investment: the customer investor with his retail purchase and
subscription fees, and the publisher invests with content updates and
expansions to go along with dedicated customer support. If  href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/node/52099">now truly is
the time for the rise of F2P games, developers and publishers
have to figure out how to grow investment just like P2P games. In a
two-part miniseries, I’ll explore how players view their investment
first and then how publishers can demonstrate their investment to
consumers and stake their claim on the MMOG industry.

style="margin: 10px; border-collapse: collapse; float: right; width: 148px; height: 185px;"

href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/node/29625"> style="border: 0px solid ; width: 200px; height: 200px;" alt=""

Players who
shell out $100 for a collector's edition usually stick with a game for
the first month.

The typical P2P game costs $50 at the retailer in the United
States, $70-100 for collector’s editions. When a gamer shells out that
much money for a product, she’ll install it and try it out. Unless the
game is absolutely horrible, she’ll play it for the 30 days she gets
with the purchase price. The money spent is the player’s investment. If
she subscribes for $15 per month over the next 11 months, she’ll have
invested a total of $215-265 (depending on the price of the retail box)
in the game over the course of a year. style="font-style: italic;">

a player can download a F2P game at no charge. He might try it one or
two play sessions. With no money invested, time becomes his commodity.
The game has to be good immediately in order for him to invest more
time in it. That is why first impressions are more important for a F2P
game than a P2P game from the mindset of the consumer. It’s much easier
to uninstall a free game after two play sessions and say, “Oh well.
Nothing lost but my time,” than it is to uninstall a $50 retail game.

The next potential investment for the F2P gamer is the item
mall. Once a player has determined that he wants to buy a hat  href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/node/52099">rather than a
lemon, he can spend his first bit of discretionary income on
a F2P game. Let’s use  href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/taxonomy/term/1303">Atlantica
Online, one of my favorite F2P games, as an example. A gamer
might decide to purchase extra inventory space and a mercenary room
license for storing an extra unit after playing style="font-style: italic;">Atlantica for three
months. The two purchases combined cost 1,998 Gcoins, the currency of style="font-style: italic;">Atlantica Online’s
item mall. That player can buy 2,000 Gcoins for $20, and the extra
inventory space and mercenary room are permanent. He never needs to
spend money on that again, but he may decide to repeat the process and
spend another $20 after six months to get even more flexibility.
Finally, he might decide to buy 50 Oriharukan Enhance Stones so that he
has a higher chance to get better results when enhancing his gear
in-game. That also costs $20 in Gcoins. After twelve months, the player
has spent $60.

Now that they have both spent money, the P2P gamer and her F2P
counterpart must consider their time invested and the money spent
before quitting their games. The person who only plays subscription
games will be looking at another $50 startup investment, which is a
deterrent because that same $50 would buy her another three months of
her current MMOG. On the other hand, she already spends $15/month in
subscriptions, so that financial investment would not hold her back.
The F2P gamer won’t need to pay anything to download a new F2P game.
The monetary investment would depend on the setup of the new game’s
item mall, but he’d never have to spend anything if he didn’t want to
invest financially. If he moved to  href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/taxonomy/term/1234"> style="font-style: italic;">Runes of Magic,
he’d be able to buy a permanent mount, decorate his house with some
potted plants, and rent two inventory bags for the whole year for just
under $50.

style="margin: 10px; border-collapse: collapse; float: left; width: 148px; height: 185px;"

href="http://www.tentonhammer.com/node/32942"> style="border: 0px solid ; width: 200px; height: 132px;" alt=""

Online and other F2P games cost nothing to try.

Parting Thoughts

The P2P gamer spends more money in my example than the F2P
gamer, and the result is that she likely won’t make the move to the new
game. She’ll avoid a new investment, pocket the $50 for the cost of a
new game, and keep her levels of experience in the old game. Though the
startup cost of a new game may be the biggest factor in her retention,
her investment of time will mean more the longer she stays with her P2P
game. The thought of starting over on the leveling treadmill will be
too much to bear. This is almost exactly the opposite of the F2P gamer.

Finances will not influence the F2P player much so long as his
monetary investment remains below the value of a subscription game. The
bigger issue for him will be finding the game where he enjoys the
community most, which usually means hopping from one game to the next
with a tight group of friends. He’ll probably consider the $60 he spent
on Atlantica
money well spent. Besides, he can always go back to it for free if the
new game is not good. On the other hand, he’ll be very reluctant to
leave his first game if he has spent $200 or more in the item mall.
Thus, the amount of money spent over time becomes the deciding factor
for the F2P gamer.

Next time, I’ll take a look at how both P2P and F2P publishers
demonstrate their investment in a title and what they can do to retain
customers. I’ll also examine what their varying approaches mean for
their ability to capture new players and a share of the market.

The Top Ten

to page two to see Ralsu's
latest Top Ten list.

To read the latest guides, news, and features you can visit our Runes of Magic Game Page.

Last Updated: Mar 29, 2016