MMO Coverage

Select an MMO...

Even More MMOs...

Close this window
Archive

Loading... Ugliest MMO Cancellations of the '00s

Posted Thu, Dec 31, 2009 by Ethec

Welcome to the 1,240th edition of Loading...

Loading... is the premier daily MMORPG news, coverage, and commentary newsletter, only from Ten Ton Hammer.

Out with the old as we enter the two-thousand-teens tonight, and in the spirt of auld lang syne, today's Loading... has a list of the Ugliest MMO Cancellations of the '00s. Happy new year!


Become a Premium Member for LIFE for $49.95! ($29.95 for existing members. Regular price - $99.95). Get beta keys, exclusive content, contest advantages and much more. For life. Only 4 days left! Offer expires January 3, 2010, so act now.

The Pulse

You vote with what you view at Ten Ton Hammer, and the result is the Ten Ton Pulse (What is The Pulse?).

Here are today's top 5 Pulse results:

  1. World of Warcraft
  2. Lord of the Rings Online (UP 1)
  3. Dungeons and Dragons Online (down 1)
  4. EverQuest 2
  5. EVE Online

Biggest movers today:

  1. Free Realms (UP 7 to #19)
  2. Star Trek Online (UP 2 to #11)
  3. Age of Conan (UP 2 to #8)
Recent Releases
Upcoming Releases

Loading... Daily

Today is the very last day of the 00's - or the aughts, as your great grandfather might have said, and I won't attempt to bring an end to the decade with this article. Wise men from across the Internet are frantically debating when exactly the second decade of the second millenia actually begins. Rather than continuing the argument that was all the rage in y2k, I want to look at some of the MMOGs we're leaving behind as we enter 2010. Are there any common threads?

Motor City Online (cancelled 2003) - One of the few MMORPG racing games that achieved launch, EA's Motor City Online was a game before it's time. On the market at a time when many in its core demographic were still on 56k modems, lag and a lack of predictive lag behavior was a serious problem, leading to cars behaving erratically during high latency. Still, Need for Speed: World Online might pick up where MCO left off in 2010.

Earth and Beyond (2004) - Perhaps the first MMO to shift perspective between ship / vehicle and character control (a sub-genre inhabited by the likes of Auto Assault, Pirates of the Burning Sea and Star Trek Online), Earth and Beyond was a beauty, especially for its day. Likely another victim of EA's particularly inflated MMORPG expectations at the time, Earth and Beyond was cancelled due to falling subscription rates in September 2004.

Imperator Online (2005) - Envisioned as a universe where the Roman Republic survived into hyper-modernity, Imperator Online was a sci-fi game with a classical twist. If that fails to resonate with you, you're in accord with Mythic Entertainment, who hefted this Dark Age of Camelot followup while it was still in its infancy.

Wish (2005) - Promising plenty of live events, a class-less skill system, and click-driven combat (no auto-attack) before games like DDO and Age of Conan made it cool, Wish was an MMO that never came true, cancelled mid-way through closed beta. Now defunct Halifax-based Mutable Realms never came clean on what caused the cancellation aside from negative beta feedback, but ex-employees noted a lack of funding and local talent to support its small but dedicated team.

Gods and Heroes: Rome Rising (2007) - For those of us that have read and re-read Bulfinch like teenage girls read the Twilight series, Gods and Heroes promised a setting steeped in interesting and edu-taining mythology as well as a minion system that was years ahead of its time. The game actually received best-of-show awards at E3 2006, including one from Ten Ton Hammer. Perpetual Entertainment, however, succoumbed to the Herculean task of producing two MMORPGs at once (the other - Star Trek Online - is now in Cryptic Studios' hands and will see the light of day next February) and suspended Gods and Heroes development before being forced into liquidation in 2008.

Auto Assault (2007) - A game that fell prey to its human side, the most persistent criticism of Auto Assault was wooden character animations and stodgy jumping. Out-of-vehicle interaction was largely ornamental, replacing a menuing system for trading, customizing the vehicle, etc. We wonder what kind of response we would have seen had NetDevil stuck to its core strength - a pretty awesome (yet hard to group in) Matchbox cars of doomsday concept. NCSoft killed the project in 2007 and - despite NetDevil's efforts to purchase the IP - retains the rights to develop and publish Auto Assault as of this printing.

Mythos (2008) - One of the few top-tier isometric perspective MMOGs this category's ever seen, Flagship drew a small and loving beta community with this novel fantasy project. When the amorphous Hellgate: London fell on hard times, Mythos development was suspended and ultimately cancelled. Fortunately for fans, Mythos may yet live at Redbana, who owns the property and has recently begun talking. Even more fortunately, much of the original team survives at Runic Games, where the Torchlight MMORPG is under development and may, it's rumored, fully realize the original vision for Mythos.

Tabula Rasa (2009) - Despite criticisms about the lack of an auction system and tradeskill complexity, Tabula Rasa was a fast paced combat MMO reminiscent of a single player shooter (albeit a long, drawn-out one), and as such wasn't terribly friendly to grouped play. Perhaps that's the chief reason for lower than expected population number which resulted in its cancellation. NCSoft ended this one with class, however, making the last few months free-to-play, offering rewards in other NCSoft games for remaining players, and holding a last days event that tied up the storyline.

The Matrix Online (2009) - The Matrix Online was a highly innovative MMORPG at its 2005 release, with novel character development and combat and the unique chance to see the Matrix storyline unfold. Unfortunately, it was released almost two years after the final Matrix film earned its lackluster reviews, and depended on an unfamiliar mix of live events for endgame appeal. After making a slight attempt to rehab the game after purchasing it sfrom Warner Bros. and SEGA, SOE closed the game last June.

Have any more titles to add to the list? See any common threads between these titles that might hint at where MMOs have systematically gone wrong? Join the discussion in our Loading... forum.


Shayalyn's Epic Thread of the Day

From our Final Fantasy XIV News & Discussion forum

Square Enix President Outlines Final Fantasy XIV Plans to Rival WoW

This thread is from over a week ago, but since it's been necroed out of its brief slumber I thought it deserved some attention. Plus, Final Fantasy XIV promises to be one of 2010's top MMOGs, and it's never too soon to get the chatter going. Especially when the president of Square Enix, Yoichi Wada, has declared the game a solid World of Warcraft rival.

Does FFXIV have enough going for it to give WoW a run for its money? Our forum community is talking, so head on over to join the discussion.

==============================
Awesome Quotes from the Epic Thread

"SE has some heavy-steel-balls, but I hope what they say is true, that its going be serious competition for once instead of [like] all these other MMOs that can barely hold onto 200K subs that have kinda said the same thing."

- Khalus
==============================

Have you spotted an Epic Thread on our forums? Tell us!

3 new Ten Ton Hammer features today! 133 in December! 2,315 in 2009!

Exclusive Features and Guides Today at Ten Ton Hammer

  • A 2009 World of Warcraft Retrospective
    Join Ten Ton Hammer as we take a look back at all of the highlights in 2009. We have it all covered, from patch 3.1 to patch 3.3 and everything in-between. We look back at the popular viral videos, Ulduar, the Argent Tournament, and the other big highlights of the year. Stay tuned as we continue covering news in WoW and bringing you the very best guides all throughout 2010 and beyond.
  • A Second Look at Fallen Earth
    The team at Fallen Earth LLC. has been working hard at improving the game with bug fixes, graphics improvements and new content, but has it been enough? Join Medawky this week as he heads back to the harsh future to take another look at the current state of the game.
  • Aion Weaponsmithing 1-99
    Aion rewards those who put forth the effort to learn a trade, so if you're looking to learn a trade that can bring the pain, Weaponsmithing is right up your alley. You'll craft the finest weapons available to anyone for every level. If that's not appealing, we don't know what is!

Today's Hottest Content

  1. The Ten Ton Hammer Best of 2009 Awards
  2. A 2009 World of Warcraft Retrospective
  3. Going Klingon - A Star Trek Online Q&A with Zeke Sparkes
  4. 2009 In EVE Online - A Retrospective
  5. Star Trek Online Beta Journal #2 - Customize Your Captain, Crew and Ship
  6. MMOG Features Version 3.0 - A Wish List
  7. Star Trek Online: Klingons and PvP Q&A with Cryptic Studios
  8. Flying The Drake Battlecruiser in EVE Online
  9. A Second Look at Fallen Earth
  10. Dungeons & Dragons Online: New Character Build - The Summoner

Thanks for visiting the Ten Ton Hammer network, and have a very happy and safe holiday!

- Jeff "Ethec" Woleslagle and the Ten Ton Hammer team

News from around the 'Net